
The chase sequences are unrealistic, with our heroes escaping completely unscathed in the nick of time. The sentimental Spielbergian elements — childhood homes, messages from cute animals, and even fairy tales — feel completely out of place in a film aimed at teenagers and adults. The alien imagery — Roswell and crop circles — is unoriginal.
Too much, including the conveniently all-powerful alien ‘device’, and the supposed North Korean nuclear threat, remains unexplained or underdeveloped. And the script is too clunky: Spielberg clearly wanted to highlight the importance of empathy, but he didn’t need to spell it out so directly.


